Printed on August 27, 2007
Not a Member? Register Now!
Forgot Password
Editor's Note -- JonBee's Owner Responds to a Reader's Criticism of Cesar's Techniques
I am Patrice Lincoln, JonBee's owner. I can understand to a degree why you found our episode disturbing. It was disturbing watching poor JonBee desperately trying to control his situation and trying to dominate Cesar. However, JonBee was the violent participant in his rehabilitation - not Cesar. Cesar was nothing but calm and gentle with him. JonBee's violence was precisely why we needed Cesar. We had tried other trainers who recommended that we euthanize JonBee. Cesar was JonBee's last hope. Having been in the room, I can guarantee you that Cesar was not choking JonBee. If that were the case, I do not think that Scott and I would just stand by and watch our dog be choked. If you look closely you will see that Cesar held the leash right under the JonBee's chin - not around his throat which is where one would hold a leash if one wished to choke an animal. You can also see that JonBee was breathing the entire time. You can hear the primal sounds coming from deep within him.
With regard to your concern about the danger of people trying this technique at home, I would hope that people would heed Cesar's caveat in the beginning of the show about non-professionals attempting such techniques.
Our episode may have been quite different from others we have seen but it was not as you say, "made for TV." It was a repeat of what Scott and I had experienced with JonBee many times since we brought him home. JonBee did not need to be provoked to become that violent. Had it been a chore to provoke JonBee into such violent behavior, Scott and I would not allow anyone to do so for the sake of a TV show.
JonBee's rehabilitation has been miraculous for our whole family. Cesar "broke" him, just as a professional would break a wild horse. Only after a horse is broken can he be ridden. Likewise, JonBee has been broken and has now become a member of our pack. He no longer has to try to dominate the pack because he now knows he is not the boss. Our episode was filmed in October 2005. Since then we have been working with JonBee every day just as Cesar taught us, and his behavior has not relapsed one bit, nor is his spirit broken - quite the contrary - he is a happy, well-behaved, sweet, loving boy who soaks up all the love and affection we give him, and which he so deserves after the horrific abuse he endured in his first years. We love him dearly.
If the episode repeats I hope you will watch it again and pay close attention to Cesar's gentleness and calm during the rehabilitation.
Also, thank you to Pamela Garner and Molly for your encouraging words.
Categories:
Editor's Notes
3 TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: http://ngccommunity.nationalgeographic.com/admin/mt-tb.cgi/333
Download Hey Young World Part 2 Ringtone from Download Hey Young World Part 2 Ringtone on July 18, 2006 7:36 AM
(Read More)
Recent Blog Comments
- Can't wait to hear what you... on That's Right, We're Running This Show Now!
- This posting makes a major and... on An Easter Island Lesson
- I have watched "The Farm" many... on A Decade Behind Bars
- I want to know when this... on Close calls and brushes with death
- But what if you are a... on Reeling In A Whopping Catch – An Interview with President George H.W. Bush for Hooked!
Monthly Archives
- May 2009 (4)
- April 2009 (11)
- March 2009 (4)
- January 2009 (9)
- December 2008 (8)
- November 2008 (2)
- October 2008 (4)
- September 2008 (4)
- August 2008 (1)
- July 2008 (7)
- June 2008 (6)
- May 2008 (4)
- April 2008 (8)
- March 2008 (7)
- January 2008 (7)
- October 2007 (9)
- September 2007 (11)
- August 2007 (1)
- June 2007 (1)
- May 2007 (1)
- March 2007 (8)
- February 2007 (10)
- January 2007 (12)
- December 2006 (3)
- November 2006 (12)
- October 2006 (7)
- August 2006 (2)
- July 2006 (12)
- June 2006 (2)
- May 2006 (7)
- April 2006 (17)
- March 2006 (11)
- February 2006 (9)
- January 2006 (14)
- December 2005 (1)

117 Comments
Patrice Lincoln:
Thank you for those encouraging words, and for coming to Cesar's defense. That happens to be my favorite episode; having recorded it, I've seen it numbers of times, and have shown it to others as well.
Never once did we see Cesar engage in anything other than calm-assertiveness, and it was amazing to see JonBee's entire will and disposition change right in front of our eyes!
The epilogue that showed him as having become a complete "teddy bear" with you all made several of my friends go "awwww." :-)
Thank you.
Simon
After reading Cesar's blogs and the comments of all the readers I never felt the need to post a comment of my own, until now. I would have to say BRAVO to you, Patrice for defending what Cesar did to rehabilitate JonBee. I can totally understand what you went through with him. My dog, Heffer (named for a cartoon character), was like your JonBee but to a lesser degree. Fortunately enough for us, he didn't become as bad. Since first discovering the show, Heffer has become a much better pack member. A lot of people have commented that he is much better now. I would have to give credit to Cesar's methods. I never realized that my husband and I were doing everything wrong. So, once again, I stand up and applaude you!!! Good luck in the future with JonBee.
I loved that episode, it made me cry. I think that was one of Ceasers best. It showed that he really can change a dog for the best. I cannot see how anyone can criticize him in that episode. He was kind and gentle. The dog has now been given a whole new life. Come on lets give credit to whom credit is due...Way to go Ceaser, you have changed a lot of dog owners lives. Keep up the good work and lets make dogs, dogs one dog owner at a time.
I haven't been here for a few days, so I must have missed something. I'll have to go back and read through...
I am a member of several dog forums and boards where Cesar's philosophies and show are discussed. There are also a few boards of which I am not a member, where Cesar bashing seems to be the norm. It is always based on human emotional reactions, fear, and ignorance. Mostly beginning with "I heard this or that from so-and-so..."
When we put our human emotion and neediness aside, put the needs of the dog first, and really look at what Cesar is offering to the world of dogs and owners alike, it's incredible.
I'm so glad to hear from JonBee's owners. It's good to hear how well things are going. It's obvious they have done the follow-up work, and JonBee is now secure and happy in his pack. Another great success story!
I had a lab many years ago, who hated to be placed on her back with a passion. But it was important that she learn to submit to this, because her back and neck would go out, and it was the only way I could adjust her. She learned to let me put her on her back, and it was also done in a calm and assertive manner.
There is a big difference between the brutal handling of "Show them who's boss!" and Cesar's calm demeanor of "Follow the leader", namely gentle compassion.
I hope someday more people will get hold of their emotions, and see what's really going on...
Way to go Cesar! And, kudos to Scott and Patricia for hanging in there for JomBee, and all of the other dogs you've helped and rehomed!
My husband and I have been watching Ceasar for a few months now and are completely awe struck at how his techniques (even for me as a rookie) work! As for JomBee, my heart was touched. What an incredible turn around for a dog that Anywhere else would have been put down without a second thought. I am proud to see humans with the heart and ability to 'redeem' animals. It is our job as "caretakers" of the world around us to redeem those that we can. Redemption is not just for people. I think that's the biggest thing I take from Cesar, his ability to redeem the unredeemable. There is hope (not just for the dogs but for the people that are around them as well)!
Dear Patrice,
I have watched the show twice (I paid a special attention after reading the comment from Eyes for lies), and never saw any choking or violence on Cesar's side. He was only calm and assertive.
You and your husband are doing a terrific job rescuing the dogs, and sticking with JonBee. Just recently I found out that a person I know put a dog down, for agression. I met the dog, she was the calmest thing ever, but apparently she bit the owner. What broke my heart was that the dog was a rescue, and someone spend time finding her a new home, and there was another family who wanted to adopt her, for her to die only a few months later. I wish the owner would watch Cesar, and see how you and your husband didn't give up on a dog that was 100 times more agressive.
Dogs are wonderful creatures, and everyone who saves them is a real hero.
I'm so happy to hear JonBee is still doing so well! As someone who works in an animal hospital where we've had to put down animals because there is no one like Cesar around I'm glad to see a technique that's not painful for the dog or owner. I'd much rather see JonBee go through a few minutes of feeling a little uncomfortable then to have had to put him down.
I think Cesar's techniques should be required learning for anyone in Vet school or taking animal behavior classes. I just wish we had a dog psychology clinic here on the east coast.
Keep up the great work Cesar, and if the Lincoln's are reading this please give JonBee a big hug from the east coast.
Yes - I agree with DK...
that episode was awesome to watch...Cesar has a true gift, which he has developed ( same category as Monty Roberts, the HORSE whisperer...they understand the animal and where it is coming from and why they do whatever they are doing....)
and yes, I would also hope that for situations like this people use common sense and DO NOT TRY these techniques themselves, but rather try to find a professional that is of the same mind as Cesar.I can't say enough good things about him, wish we all had some of that talent.
p.s.
Thank you Patrice Lincoln for coming to Cesar's defense. I am amazed that people are criticising him.
I had a Border Collie who, as a puppy, tested our dominance constantly. By the time he was 6 months, he thought he ran the pack and bit us badly a few times. Once was when we tried to put the leash on him after a play period and another was when he tried to eat an unattended hamburger. He ALWAYS bit us when we tried to brush and groom him.
This was the first dog I ever owned and I was clueless about establishing structure, boundaries and training. Thankfully, someone recommended a professional trainer who and we hired her. She owned some relatives of our dog, so she was familiar with his tendencies and traits. She had me "set him up" by trying to groom him...and he tried to bite me. Then the trainer instructed me to push him to the ground and hold him there until he was calm and submissive. He had to stop fighting me, growling, snarliing and baring his teeth. I had to hold him with my forearm across his neck and throat until he was limp and not even licking his lips.
Essentially, this was the same thing Cesar did with JonBee. My dog and JohBee were "broken" (like a horse!!!) and learned their true place in the family pack. There was no violence or pain--it was just psychological. But I realize it might have looked like we were hurting our dog to the untrained eye.
This was really the only way to handle such a dog. By the way, our dog was instantly changed and this only took 20 minutes. He became a trusted beloved friend to the entire neighborhood and the only dog mothers trusted around young children and babies.
Cesar is brilliant!
I have a 18/month doberman male who has bitten me twice when i get nearor on his sleeping area help i have had dobermans for years never have been bitten help
Several years ago, I worked with a 4-month-old Jindo dog which was being boarded and trained at a local kennel. I have seen the unbridled fury these dogs can provide, and with virtually no provocation. Everyone at that kennel was bitten, to one degree or another. The owners were terrified of the dog. I have to say though, it never bit me, but not for lack of trying on his part. I padded well, and refused to be intimidated. He was smart, but even while walking quietly at a heel, on a loose leash, would turn and launch to bite the trainer's or owner's arm like corn-on-the-cob. Just like JonBee's owner described, bang bang bang and then he'd go right back to his perfect heel like nothing had happened. He was unpredictable and violent. These dogs may be small, but they are powerful, and they can be fearless.
I have to give Cesar a standing ovation for the way he dealt with JonBee. He did what had to be done to save that dog from being killed, and he did it with style and compassion. I also agree that no one should attempt handling a dog of that magnitude unless they understand full and well they are putting themselves in harm's way. Anyone who thinks they can handle a dog the way Cesar does, without extensive practice and knowlege, and who is foolhardy enough to try, deserves what he gets. I have never seen a faster biting dog than a Jindo. Cesar's comparison to a rattlesnake is on target with their behavior and speed. That is probably also why such primal sounds came from JonBee during the episode.
My hat is off to you, Cesar, and to JonBee's owners for allowing you to show what can be done with such extreme cases. I know it was a disturbing sequence for those who have never seen dogs in crisis, but he did a superb job of showing it can be dealt with, safely.
My friends and clients tell me their dogs absorb obedience training better now that they, the owners are taking back the leadership roll. Walking their dogs, then coming home and working on obedience exercises. The dogs are calmer, the owners are more relaxed, and their bond is even stronger for the effort. Everyone wins!
Cesar, you ROCK!
I am so impressed with Cesar, I have done a couple different training programs (locally),with our dog.Charlie is well trained but had one specific problem, which by watching the show Cesar helped me get into his mindset and figure out what was going and to think from Charlie perspective.I have been working with him and I feel his mind is healthy again,and I am the leader of the pack.Thank you Cesar Millian!!!
Dear Scott & Patrice,
I praise you both for the hard work that you do. I have been watch Cesar's show for a while and his ways of doing things is all good for the minor to the major issues. If anyone gets information from his show is that "being calm and assertive" with your dog.
I myself help out with rescuing dogs in Nebraska.
Keep up the good works, Cesar and all to do rescue.
Since I do not read all posting, I was not aware of the criticism against Cesar about how he handled JonBee. I myself was very impressed to see this episode. I think overall episodes for this season are much more educational and in depth compared to the first season. He deals with variety of problems with various techniques.
As the owners said, Cesar was the last straw for JonBee.I did not see Cesar's handling as cruel or hurting the dog. He was "breaking" the dog, just like horses. I used to ride horses (English) and there are times when you have to physically discpline the horse. Otherwise, the horse may become too dangerous to ride (thinking he can get away with bucking people off, etc.) I am so glad for Scott and Patrice that JonBee (love the name!!) is doing great.
I am not familiar with Jindo breed but they seem to be very similar to Akita or other hunting dogs in Japan. I am from Japan and most of the dog bites or even death in Japan are caused by Akitas. I cringe when I see some Akitas are owned by people who do not know how to set the rules and boundaries. Akitas need strong (or dominating) owners who can be the true leaders.
Hooray to Cesar!!
Whenever I hear a negative comment about the work Cesar is doing, I think it's important to remember there are some dog training professionals, who are feeling the impact of Cesar's show.
For some of them, this is a difficult time with a lot at stake. They are being asked for details of what Cesar is doing, and some of them don't have the answers because his philosophies, (although right on, IMO), are very different than some of the schools of thought which have been studied and taught over the last 15 years or so.
Some of what he does, can LOOK like what are considered "old school" methods, if you don't understand what he's doing. Some of these methods were quite harsh, and were used by a few very brutal people, to boot.
Having pretty much "seen it all" in working with dogs, and checking out just about every method out there for the last 40 years, I have to say what Cesar is doing IS different. His description of calm/assertive leadership, dog psychology, canine communication, pretty much everything, is from a new perspective...and he's right on the mark.
I feel compassion for what some of these trainers are going through right now, but this was a needed change. I hope they can get past this difficult time, keep an open mind, and take a closer look at what is really going on.
Cesar's methods and philosophies, are the future.
Now, if we can just get him to open up that institute, so we can get started on the next generation of "Dog Whisperers"...
The episode is without a doubt a defining moment for Cesar's philosophical perspective as it relates to dog psychology and rehabilitation method. Simply put: it is brilliant.
I personally enjoy hearing the criticisms since it allows me the opportunity of correcting what, in many cases, espcially amongst non-professionals, is either ignorance or misapprehension. We must be patient with those who have always thought within a "humanizing grid." Old habits are or ideas are hard to break, so we need to be patient, and cease each opportunity of educating folk on where their misapprehensions begin: dogs are, after all, animals. :-)
I am currently taking my dog through obedience class, and smile at the looks I receive when I mention Cesar's show. They are not bashful about mentioning their disagreements, to be sure. However, in nearly every case, once they voice their disagreement, it is clear that they lack any real argument, as their contentions are typically based on ignorance, second hand information, misapprehension, or, from my perspective, a proper distinction between a human being and an animal no matter what "personality name" we may give to it.
Cesar's philosophy and method demonstrate that we can maintain such distinctions, without compromising the needs of the dogs, or our full capacity to love them as wonderful pets! In actuality, we place ourselves in the position of doing both to the fullest.
Thanks, Cesar.
I am glad Ceasar came along with his methods. His impact amazes me. I knew I was thoroughly impressed, but it is nice to see that other people are encouraged by the pack mentality as well. It's sad people can't appreciate him the way most of us do, but what is the alternative? Go back to putting perfectly rehabilitable animals to sleep? No! Probably not...there is no going back now. As the song goes...Ain't no stopping us now.
As someone who helps run a rescue, this episode was exactly what I needed to see - that even the most terrifying dogs can be tamed and made a valuable member of a pack.
I've only been watching since January and I cannot even explain how much I've already learned and put to good use with my own 3 dogs, my foster dog - a hurricane Katrina survivor not only traumatized from the storm but who had suffered years of neglect at the hands of her owner, and several other dogs we have recently taken into our group.
My only regret is that I did not see some of his shows before now. Our rescue had to euthanize a beautiful pit girl back in early November because of her aggression which eventually led her to attack a kennel worker where she was housed. I now know the many mistakes we made with her and I will NEVER make those mistakes again and Cesar made that possible. I wish they could clone him and send one to Michigan. There are soooo many questions I have about other animals in our rescue that need so much work
3 Dogs just came in that are so scared that they just roll over on their backs and pee all over themselves. We've never had one this bad, never mind 3 of them. How do you walk a dog that doesn't know how to walk and completely freaks out when approached with a collar/leash? Do I just proceed, remaining calm and ignoring the dog's distress? I just don't know where to begin.
PATRICE,
You go girl! I can't believe anyone would question Cesar Millan. I truly will not take any dog advice from anyone but Cesar anymore. He is so Awesome! Cesar is so calm and never at all cruel or making a dog uncomfortable. Patrice I'm so glad you wrote this blog, and I'm so glad to hear JonBee is doing well. Keep up the great work. :D
I have to say,
ever sence I have been watching Dog Whisperer (about two months now) I have noticed people on the streets and I think 'they aren't walking their dog right' or 'they shouldn't give the dog attension when he's so hiper like that'. It really makes me see from the dogs point of view, and now I can tell when a dog is "Dominant over the owner" just by watching how they walk. Sometimes I just want to run over there and SHOW THEM HOW ITS DONE. Cesar is truly an inspiration and I think everyone should have the knowledge on how to REALLY "love your dog". People think kisses and hugs is going to solve all of the dog's problems. Boy are they wrong.
~Chantel
P.S. I can't wait for Dog Whisperer tomarrow night!!!!!
Debbie;
Are you permitted to lend an inkling where I might find those forums you are speaking of? I would love to find a group that discusses Cesar's way. I will be attending his seminar in Ohio in July also.
Paula
Paula,
If you do a general web search of "dog forum" it will take you to the all of the general listings. I'll let you do the searching and see what you can find.
Each site has it's own personality and rules of conduct. Some are 100% for what is called positive method training, some are more advanced sites with Schutzhund or guard dog training, some are filled with the general public, where others contain more trainers and canine professionals, some sites are new, and some are older, more established sites with a core group of members who all have known each other for a long time. They are all so different!
This blog is currently the best place to talk with other people who understand what Cesar is doing, and support his work, but things are changing on some of the other sites.
I find if you are compassionate and kind to others, maintain your sense of humor, and stick to the topics without getting emotional or personal, you can make some great friends with similar interests, who also love dogs.
Have fun and happy hunting! And remember, a little kindness goes a long way! See you around!
Debbie
No matter what you do there will always be critics. I think Cesar did a fantastic humane job and had he not been able to "get through" to this dog he would have been euthanised. I am very impressed with the results and I know the dog has to be happier.
Re: Debbie RTW
The necessity of rolling your Lab reminded me of a thread on a forum when a vet tech mentioned gently pushing her dog on its side to teach it to be calm under restraint at the vet's office. The reaction of some people was utterly fanatic, comparing even lightly manipulating the dog to an "alpha roll" and abuse.
Treating an animal like it's made of glass, IMO, is doing it a disservice. I've seen people criticizing Cesar's methods, as well, but they always seem to focus on the spots of "negative reinforcement," rather than appreciating how much positivity he incorporates.
I've been around dogs for decades, and I'm a firm believer that one size does NOT fit all. Some dogs may be fine with strictly positive reinforcement; others may need corrections.
I have been watching Cesar's show faithfully since I discovered it during his first season, and he has been such an inspiration. I learn something new, however small, from every situation on his show. Even rewatching the Katrina episode this morning I realized it was time for me to put aside my grief at the loss of our beloved Sheltie Paris 10 days ago, and show our heartbroken Sheltie Crosby that it is time to move on and rebuild his confidence.
I also watched this episode and was amazed at the transformation in JonBee. What I saw was calm but firm strength, affection and acceptance from Cesar in the face of JonBee's aggressive and somewhat violent reactions. It was obviously distressing for Patrice to watch, but I have the utmost respect for she and her husband's love, courage and determination to help JonBee correct his inappropriate behavior. He's a beautiful dog and deserves a wonderful life.
As someone new to handling dogs (I held a life-long fear of big dogs and was clueless in understanding them), I am ever-grateful that I began this adventure when Cesar had a forum to dispense his knowledge.
I took responsibility for a 4-month old large breed, abused, fear-agressive dog over a year and a half ago).
Soon, I realized there was more to learn than imagined leaving me often overwhelmed by my ignorance.
An excellent dog training class, MANY books and videos on training methods plus the scattered and passionate opinions and advice from nearly everyone still couldn't help me understand the key reasons WHY I was failing my dog. My dog-training class leader was knowledgable about dogs but couldn't handle an animal novice as myself; his impatience with me was discouraging).
NOW, however, I have had an exquisite education through Cesar's shows and video and have great confidence in myself, as seen in the results of my now 80-lb. 2-year old Yogi who shows me just how well I'm doing (very well...albeit, not finished). Thank you.
Thank you Patrice for giving your view of the event. I, for one, watched that episode and said "Yes! I know people will find this disturbing, but they should be disturbed in order to break out of their old habits."
My first dog, Portia, became a red-zone dog. We had her as a puppy, but treated her like a child. We ended up with a six-month old puppy terrorist that was biting us all the time. At that time (20 years ago) there were no puppy training courses or behaviorialists. One day I "accidently" did essentially what Cesar did with JonBee when I had finally had enough. I put the leash on her, and gave her a "down" command. I ended up with attacking me. Despite the blood dripping from my hands, my brain clicked into some cool inner alpha dog zone, and I just held that snarling, writhing dog down until she stopped. Then I calmly started petting Portia as long as she stayed calm. Portia and I went on to do obedience work, and she bacame my best friend. Despite the fact that I worked up to the point of being able to stop her dead in her tracks with a look, Portia continued to test me until her last days--it as a 14-year training program in self-empowerment.
It is a very disturbing thing to do, but like tough love for teenagers, it is sometimes necessary. Kudos to you folks for giving JonBee the chance to reclaim life.
The session on JonBee was riveting. It helped me understand my dog's behavior.
I have a 3 month old standard poodle puppy who was biting me and my clothes. This puppy is so smart and wants to be the alpha in the family. This morning I used Cesar's technique for no more than 20 minutes and he has not bitten since. I know it will take consistency to make sure the behavior is stopped. He is being trained to work with me in my practice as a therapy dog. Thank you Cesar and to all those who have contributed to this blog.
-- Linda
My husband & I both think Ceasar is awsome. We both watch every Friday night. I usually grocery shop on my way home & if I see I won't make it in time he records it so we can watch itlater.
I think ALL of his shows are Great, but this one in particular blew me away! It was incrediable to see him calm this dog. I would have never thought it could have been done. He truly has a special gift.
We rescued a Greyhound from an adoption . We have had her for about 3yrs. I try & get tips from him to help me with our dog. We also had a Shar-Pei which was 8 when he died this past October. You are so right about the greiving process. Your dog can tell when you are greiving & also goes through greiving.
It is mainly retraining the people as much or more so than retraining the dog. I know I was treating her more as a baby then being more of a leader & in control. I guess I felt sorry for what she had been through. Need to live for the moment and not feel sorry for what she has gone through in the past. I do try and learn from your shows. I have allot to learn & a ways to go.
Thank you Cesar for helping me see my dog & all dogs in a different way.
Janet
Being a 'natural trainer' I know that you must do enough to get results in order to be effective. Always keeping in mind that no harm is done emotionally or physically to the animal.
Please understand that a quality animal trainer never 'breaks' an animal - either horse nor dog! If you know what you are doing you 'gentle' the animal and teach. This lasts a lifetime and never causes the animal to fear the human only love and respect him/her.
Thanks
First let me say I am totally impressed with Cesar, his understanding of dog psychology, and his desire to help dogs. I like that he works with purebred & mixed breed dogs, wealthy & not-so-wealthy owners, low self-esteem, dangerous behavior ... etc. His pack episodes are mind-blowing. BUT ... I cringe when folks write about 'breaking' a dog, just like 'breaking' a horse. The goal is never to break but gentle or socialize. Monty Roberts uses the term 'join up' and perhaps folks can come up with a similar term for dogs. Some may say it's only a word but words have power and energy. The positive power and energy that Cesar projects are inspiring; let the words be the same.
Sue Ellen,
That's great! I've heard and used these words before, too. That's exactly what "it" is!
Some things I've found helpful with dogs, came from having horses. The psychology is different, but they're both social animals, which respond best with a leader in charge.
The term join-up" describes this very well! It's the moment you are recognised, and acknowledged as the pack leader, by the dog.
Denise wrote:
"3 Dogs just came in that are so scared that they just roll over on their backs and pee all over themselves..... How do you walk a dog that doesn’t know how to walk and completely freaks out when approached with a collar/leash?"
Hi Denise,
They are fearful because they haven't had a calm assertive leader. They don’t know how to behave so they give extreme submission. Checkout Cesar’s shows with the Great Dane that wouldn’t go into the school and the small dog that wouldn’t walk on leash. Also watch the recent episode where Cesar calmly moves a small dog (the one that was attacking his E-collar) into a corner, then puts a leash on it.
At first don’t direct where or how they walk, just moving on leash is a good step. Some fearful dogs can improve by living with calm submissive dogs (as long as they aren’t fear-aggressive) that know how to act around humans. The fearful dog will follow the other’s lead. Keep a good handle on your emotions and the emotions of anyone else around. You must visualize your goal and have confidence that he’ll do as you ask. If you have fear, reservations, mistrust when you work with the dog he cannot trust you as leader. When you walk all your energy is focused on going forward, confident that the dog will walk with you. The dog will only gain confidence when he trusts you as leader. You need a plan before you work with each dog. How will you influence his emotions (and thereby his behaviors) to get what you want with minimal resistance? Head-on fights are counterproductive with fearful dogs because conflict reinforces the fearful mindset. You must master redirection and calm influence. Watch Cesar’s shows where he “herds” dogs with his body and gets them to calm down *before* he touches them or puts on a collar. You might also rewatch the show with Booker, the country Vizla turn city dog. Exercise was a huge release for him, he could release alot of the anxious energy in the environment he was afraid of.
I did not see this episode, but can relate to a professional saying you should euthanize a dog because it cannot be retrained. I give you a lot of credit for caring enough about your dog to seek help from Cesar. One dog should not be replaced with another, nor should it be disposed of because it has a problem. As dog owners, we are responsible to help our pets in every way possible, especially if that means getting appropriate training for issues that make a dog aggressive. It sounds like you have set a good example for any dog owner who is currently experiencing a problem with their dog, but has yet to seek professional help. I'm glad it worked out for you and JonBee.
I missed that episode as well but can not see Cesar harming any animal. In fact that is the difference I see in "his" training than in other trainers, his care and love for all the dogs around him.
I have an 18 month old Staffordshire Bull Terrier (Pitbull) named Bubba, though we have paid a good amount of money for training, he is still not completely under my/our control yet. He was boarder trained (something I do NOT recomend) at 6 months. He left our home a half trained fat pitbull puppy dog and came home a scared, half starved greyhound who only knew how to sit and lay on command. After 5 weeks away he forgot all we had taught him(fetch, paw and so on)even forgot us. We soon fattened him back up and pulled him back to where we started at. Now he is bigger and his problems are bigger as well. He gets pushy sometimes when he wants attention and craves rough attention often. All that money I spent on training that didn't work and just after watching 3 shows I have more control over and respect from Bubba then ever.
I have learned from the show that its not Bubba being bad its us not doing our job as dog owners. We need the training more than he does. Everything Cesar says is just common sense and I believe his ways work better than most because of his respect for dogs. Most trainers that I have come in contact with do not consider the household a pack, meaning family. Leader of the pack just means parent. Both trainers I looked at when seeking training for Bubba said he would bite us one day for letting him on the couch or bed with us, "Treating him like part of the family is dangerous in big dogs" they both said. I disagree and feel control and complete respect is just around the corner, after all it is I who needs the training. Bubba not being part of the family is not an option, we all love Bubba dearly. I have 3 teen daughters and Bubba does get his name from "baby brother".
P.S. Someone spoke of Cesar founding a school for dog whisperers... I say "Cesar thats the next best thing to cloning yourself!"
i have to give caesar all the credit with handling all of those dogs in every episode.i watch all the new episodes friday @11pm and i learn what to do with my dogs i have a 13 yr old basset hound/dachshund mix female and a 10 yr old chow mix female.
and my chow mix shows alot of food aggression around other dogs.and i'm trying to get her to understand that no one
will hurt her but if you run your hand or foot underneath her hind end she jumps. i have been thinking of enrolling her into agility since she is a high energy dog.
i also help care for my aunt's dog, he's a miniature dachshund/mini collie mix and he is a biter. if you touch his toys or food you're in trouble. and one night i got up and went into the kitchen and when i did i told him "shhh" and he stayed there laying on the floor. he is gonna be turning 8 yrs old at the end of this month and i told my aunt that she needs to start watching the dog whisperer to train her dog because if she doesn't i'm afraid to have any friends over because he can't stand strangers.i told my mom that i wanted to get pitbull terrier and she looked at me as if i was nuts. because i really love dogs and pitbull terriers are my favorite. i had one and i don't think that they are mean, its all in the way they are brought up. and i'm hoping day my dream of owning and rehab. and retraining fighting dogs will come true. i've learned alot about how train strong willed dogs since i started watching the dog whisperer and i hope make this dream happen to.. thanx caesar you've done really well so far and i really hope you will continue helping people and their crazy pets :)!
THANK GOD FOR CESAR! Fact is most people are stupid by nature and jealous! The see what he is doing and either think oh its cruel (that would be the stupid folks) and their are others that say oh that is not how you do it (that would be the jealous folks) case and point is cesar gets the job done and gets it done correctly.
Im glad my life long evaluations have proven to be pretty accurate. I have polished up some things I was applying incorrectly but now that I have been wathing his show since day 1 I cannot get enough! (I DVR it)
When he first went on air I wanted him to come out and help us with a male dog we had to correct his aggression for anyone outside of the home. Times were not so great and money was tight so we could not fly to him or fly him to us. In either case, this is a man I MUST MEET BEFORE I DIE!
I only wish I could train with him as his student and help others. I must say i was jealous of the two women on the katrina episode that were his students! hahaha But hopefully one day I will have the pleasure of working with such a qualified example of a dog man.
- E.Garcia
How may I view the episode regarding the "aggressive" JonBee. I have two Great Danes that I am having aggression problems with and desparately need help getting their behavior to an acceptable level. I Live in the Phoenix area. Does Cesar ever come out this way???
Cesar's methods work and I have proven them many times. I have even told an animal control officer about Cesar's show after he saw how well behaved my pugs are. I am a foster and do volunteer work at our animal shelter. I was glad to see Cesar rehabilitate such a dangerous dog and train the owners. My niece has the same kind of dog and the hardest part is training my niece. She does watch Cesar's show and that dog is much better. If someone bashed Cesar's technques, then are really telling me that they have a lot to learn about dogs.
Hi-I have not seen my problem anywhere on this site. Does anyone have any ideas on how to stop my dog from Barking when someone is in front of my house? or when company comes, he jumps up on them in a happy way..but this is not good and his barking is driving me crazy. Thanks..
how do you get to be on the show? I did not see a place to inquire. Thanks
To All -
I've been training dogs for 25 years -show obedience, retriever training, and mostly basic good pet manners in a large suburb of NYC. I cannot praise Cesar enough, not only for his mastery of canine behavior, which to me is truly spiritual, but also for his presentation of "dog facts" to the owners. I cant tell you how many times since finding this series I've been struck with the concise and well thought out explanations and directions he gives. I'm sure many of you who help others with their dogs have been struck by how simple he seems to make it! I admit that against my own better judgement, I've tried to cater to those who "don't mind if Buster jumps on me, but I don't want him jumping on anyone else". IT JUST DOESNT WORK, PERIOD. Where I live, dog parks are proliferating, with escalating aggression and pandemonium ensuing. The recent episode on dog parks is one that I would like to give every student of mine FREE OF CHARGE, in hopes that people will see that unleashing a hyper, frustrated, unexcercised, untrained dog in a dog park spells disaster for SOMEONE... I am so grateful to Cesar for that episode in particular, and for his whole series. I hope he will start a school to train trainers!
I really have been enjoying the show, esp the session with JonBee. I really thought Cesar did a super job helping the dog release all that tension and pent up energy.
If people only understood how dogs truly operate. I never realized it until I started watching the show. I really started thinking about how dogs are and they really are nothing like people think they are.
Thanks Cesar for clarifying dog life and how they live it and how we can enter it. If humans lived more like dogs, there would be less sturm and drang.
20 years ago I became my pack leader. With the help of a very talented and committed trainer I learned how to communicate with my dog. What led me to this point was a black Lab we called “the hound from ****”. While she was physically beautiful and athletic, she was the penultimate alpha. She did it ALL her way. I had dogs all of my life and trained them, but never one like her. She was very destructive and impossible to contain.
After 2 years my wife gave me an ultimatum. The pound or a real training program with a professional; TODAY! With much skepticism I took her to a trainer who specialized in extreme cases. A 4 week boarding training was agreed to; two for the dog, two for the people. When I first saw the trainer handle the dog after two weeks I did not recognize her. She was perfect for him. Then I took the leash. She’s back! That’s when my training started. But I was committed. Every day was training day. Every negative was a training opportunity. And she became one of the most highly trained obedience dogs in the state. She was even used in a movie because of her training. Sit was “sit forever until you are released” and every door needed permission. And now we took her everywhere. She became a true part of our lives and when she passed away from age it was one of the saddest days of our lives.
But the truly sad part of this story is that someone shot a video of a training session at the kennels where my trainer worked. Although he was not the one in the video, he took responsibility for the employee’s actions. The news media got hold of the video from a disgruntled employee, cut it to the most damaging segment, and broadcast it with a scathing commentary. My trainer was out of business. The video was very similar to segments with JonBee, only cut to eliminate any of the commentary of the trainer or an explanation of what was happening.
I know that this trainer saved countless dogs from the pound and will no longer engage in dog training because of this experience. The world lost a great dog trainer, one who taught me and many others how to really be with dogs.
Our dogs are the best thing in our life and we are now avid bird dog field trialers. Our dogs are some of the top Brittany bird dogs in the country and have many top national awards. We owe so much to this trainer, who like Cesar, taught us that we had to live in the pack as alphas of our pack in order for our pack to function. It was a bold move to show the JonBee episode and I applaud both Cesar and you for your contribution.
I very much enjoy watching Cesar's show. As a behaviorist, myself, I find we all learn from each other. Not one of us should claim to know the best way to train all or any dog. I disagree, completely, with the use of prong or choke collars, in any situation. From the Studies of the HSUS and other organizations, the study concluded that the use of such collars, long term, will and does cause damage to the neck. Not only did the study conclude long term neck damage, the study also measured aggression. Over 70% of the test dogs, 200 in total, demonstrated aggression, as they began mature adults, with the use of chokes and prongs. The theory was simple: The dogs became older, strong and got sick of being hurt and finally rebelled. Choke collars HURT...Prong collars hurt. They work because they hurt, not because the cause a "like bite" response inside the dog. Cesars technique of using his hand as a mouth is very on target and is fantastic. The chokes and prongs are devices that cause pain, thus the dog submits because pain is induced. They work VERY fast because it hurts. Problem with such collars, only very experienced trainers and behaviorists understand the timing and to the degree to "yank".I used to believe in them, however, after that study was released, in 2001, I hung them up and began using much more rewarding methods.
Just one persons input.
S.
I haven't read the supposed negative comments concerning that episode. But having seen that episode, anyone that feels this was cruel is not observant. Go Cesar and see you in Utah at your seminar.
Joe Mudd
I have had two dogs over the last 16 years. I've invested in home personal/professional training sessions for both dogs along with group obedience sessions. Total of $1,200. It's been a valuable experience.
One thing I finally "got" is that you don't just train a dog and wipe your hands free and say it's done. It's a daily commitment. There is a lot of technicality to it. Cesar is right when he rehabilitates dogs and trains people. His ability to understand the difference between the dog psyche and the human psyche is genius.
Dogs need a great deal of attention and I commend Cesar for committing to a pack of 47 dogs, including difficult cases, I'm sure.
My current dog, Misha, is a good gal. She is confident, loved, and calm-submissive, obedience trained to the nth degree. She is not food aggressive. I can take any food or bone away from her at any time without her objection.
My only problem with her is when visitors come over; she gets very excited and rears and jumps on my guests no matter how much I try to correct this behavior.
She does tend to bark heavily when the house is approached by people; and I do not want to correct this as it does discourage unwanted visitors. Her barking sounds like the "hound from hell" five times larger than she really is, although she would never attack a person, and of that, I'm 99.9% positive. But I wonder if this behavior should be discouraged.
I guess if you know enough to ask the question, you pretty much know the answer. My guess is to work with the cooperation of the invited guests coming to the door and the dog at the same time. And use the Cesar "ssshhhhh" technique, put her into calm-submissive mode while the guests cooperate with the little training thing. It's kind of easy to just throw up your hands when having dinner guests and say "oh well". After all, she calms down after five minutes. I'd just like to break her of this habit of jumping. Any ideas?
Well, this was quite a discussion thread. (I needed a break from the Grant and Kelly "Wifestyles" episode message boards from last week's Dr. Phil show, so this was a nice break.)
Hey Janet the dog whisperer also comes on the weekends too like 8:00am or 7:00am for sat. & sunday. cya Danessa
Patrice, I was glad to see JonBee has continued to work out so well. I wasn't so much as disturbed as amazed that Cesar could calm him down so well (and didn't get bit!) I am glad to see you kept him though instead of adopting him out like the other dogs. Because I wondered if he were to fall in the hands of someone who didn't have Cesar's training he might revert back to being aggessive?
That would be an interesting topic to cover.
My lab was also treated at caesars facility. He was "corrected' repeated to the point of strangulation and has been on a respirator for the last 48 hours. The medical bills are mounting (nearing $15,000) and my lab remains in critical condition clinging to life. So those of you worried about the level of correction from this man are right to be concerned. Since the incident I have not heard a word from Caesar nor his employees, no apology, no offer of aid, no simple concern over whether my dog is alive or dead.
To anyone reading these comments, in reference to LA OWNER,
Please don't feed the troll!!
NO TROLLING
What is a troll? It's a person who posts something which is bound to stir people up and then sits back and watches as dozens of people jump in and start arguing. Sometimes trolls get their friends to join in or post under different names. Generally they will do anything it takes to get attention. If you see a message like this, please try and refrain from replying to it - it may well be locked/deleted anyway.
I was inspired as well by this episode. I apprentice under a master dog trainer who is often a last chance for many dogs, and I remember clearly the first time a watched this simulated wolf fight. The emotions it stirs are strong, but we must remember there are no emotions with dogs when this happens, only reactions. My only query regarding this episode was why didn't Cesar exhaust the dog first like he does in so many other episodes. That is one vital tool I've learned from him, exhaust the dog and he will submit much sooner. I am dedicated to learning his techniques, attending his dog psychology school, and when I become certified, I plan to give free monthly seminars to help spread this vital information. In my area, and I'm sure many areas now, anything not purely positive motivation is seen as cruel and unusual punishment, and too many dogs are being put down because they fail at this method of training. It angers me and I intend to make it a personal mission to change the minds of these people, especially shelters who require that animals adopted from them attend food-motivated training. Often, that is a recipe for disaster, and the owners, fully trusting the shelter's advice, give up when their dog isn't motivated by food or praise alone.
I watched the episode of JonBee with awe!!! I was already hooked on Ceaser's methods, but this particular episode was by far one of the best I've seen! AS a lover of all animals I was so happy that Patrice and her husband were able to get Ceaser to come and help them. I shudder to think what would have become of JonBee had it not been for Ceaser. How anyone could watch him working with these animals and and dare to say anything negative is beyond my comprehension. Keep up the good work, Ceaser!!
Wow, I find it very disconcerting that my reply regarding LA OWNERS's posting was removed from this blog, considering I was trying to warn people away from taking it seriously, just like Sparrow. yet LA OWNER's posting is still there. This is very sad. I guess I'm going to no longer contribute to these postings if that's how the censorship is going to be handled. I hope that all of you whom I've corresponded with on this particular listing and on others continue to develop your great relationships with your dogs.
Well now, something is amiss because when I posted the last message and the blog refreshed, my original message shows once again! Go figure!
I just sent a comment. My e-mail address is correct. Soorry you did not submit it.
I do not believe that you are the owner of this dog and it distresses me that you take this opportunity to slur someone’s name without even knowing the details. This posting is filled with misinformation. Cesar Millan had nothing to do with what happened to this dog. Cesar doesn't even know this dog or the owners. This was a freak accident that happened on my watch. I stayed with the owners the entire time after it happened. I have called the hospital several times every day and have been down to visit 3 times since then. I have kept in touch with the owners and we are on good terms. I have contributed to the medical bills (which are not $15,000) and I have asked their forgiveness. They have graciously accepted my apology. The dog is walking and eating and going home. Cesar’s methods are humane, effective and his dogs love him. What kind of person would try to ruin the reputation of someone they don't even know?
I concur with LA DOG TRAINER.
LA Owner has no business sullying the name of Cesar Millan or his staff. Don't talk about what you don't know.
On the intro of the Dog Whisperer show, Cesar has a big blue plastic pool for his dogs. I love it!!!! Does anyone know where I can find one for my dogs?? I've searched everywhere with no luck.
Alice
maybe kmart wal mart target costco not sure hun sorry Danessa
I am so happy to see others out there are watching the show and getting educated. I live in south Florida and can't seem to find anyone who watches or practices his methods. Good to find a place to fot in.
I have a jindo that looks just like jonbee (just a little smaller cause she is a remale). Although my dog wasn't exactly like jonbee she too is very agreesive. I don't know why but her agreesion seems be to getting worse. For the first three years, she never attempted to bite anyone or anything but now, we have to muzzle her everytime we go out. She also kills any animals that come into our backyard.
I must admit to having been upset reading the comment w/regard to JonBee's episode. I've been in dogs for over 30 years and come in contact w/a few in the same vein and there was no one there to do what needed to be done. Watching Cesar was an incredible experience. I agree that that post was most likely a 'troll' looking to stir up a mess just like a charging dog. One of the things I've learned over the years is that no one 'training' method works w/all dogs when you follow the standard OB rules, but learning to read your dog's body language and gaining an understanding of the pack mentality goes a long way towards encouraging a strong partnership between an owner and his/her dog. I try to learn from each experience w/different personalities of trainers. Now is the time for all of us 'dog people' to sit back and watch and learn from someone who has a great deal to teach us. Thank you, Cesar, I'm learning something new every time you're on.
As a cyclist I encounter dogs frequently. I would like to suggest an episode where Cesar gives pointers to handling dog encounters like those we cyclists encounter.
Happy to have an opportunity to post a comment about the show. Have enjoyed all the espisodes even though I do not have a dog.
One thing I don't hear Cesear saying directly and I think is important is that what he does is as of an equal value to the wellbeing of the pet as it is to the owners. And when made evident to the owners I beleive they will be in agreement that this will be as important issue as any. The dog will be better off if it is not saddled with the responsiblity of being the top dog. When the owners realize that they have abrigated their responsibility to assert their confidence in controlling the pack eary on all will benifit.
That's is my take on what is going on and would welcome comments on it.
Thanks
RHB
I recently began watching Dog Whisper, and I am a new fan!! Cesar is excellent with both the dogs AND their owners! There is nothing more frustrating than going to the park or a walk with my dog and see another dog owner completely overpowered by "their pet". The rules of the "pack" are not complicated, but people certainly make the task of "training" their dog complicated. ALL dog owners need to watch Cesar!!
It's a sad commentary on society today when people see assertiveness, like that displayed by Cesar in the JonBee episode, and choose to interpret it as abuse. I worked with two so-called expert trainers here in New York City to rehabilitate my rescued Jack Russell, Charlie. Their answer to every issue? Give food for good behavior, ignore dog for bad behavior. While both of these techniques have their role in dog training, I find it absurd that the majority of trainers these days are scared to discipline a dog! Cesar's tips and demonstrations have given me more useful information than the hundreds of dollars I've spent on the "experts" -- information that has resulted in a significant change in Charlie's behavior and in our relationship as pack leader/follower. Thank you Cesar, and to all of you who choose to judge without truly knowing what you're talking about, understand that DISCIPLINE, delivered correctly, is a far greater way of showing love to your dog than allowing him to rule the roost.
I completely agree with Bret Koehler. We have to understand how this animals (dogs) live in the wild. To discipline a dog is a way to control their behavior. Discipline is not giving them food when they do something right nor it is beating off the animal, it is being firm and consistent with what you want. We have discipline with our kids and we as dog owners need to have discipline with our dogs too. As Cesar have been saying on his show everytime, they need structure, rules, boundaries, and limitations. The very same thing we do with our kids.
I'm a cat rescuer, myself. But I have figured out what Cesar is. (DITTO the Horse Whisperer someone noted in a comment above.)
Cesar and others are shapeshifters in the truest sense of indigenous peoples' use of shapeshifting energy -- such as the Maya, the Shuar and other Amazonian tribes. Even Robert Redford got the shapeshifting energy in order to play the part of the cinematic version of The Horse Whisperer.
Read any materials on native shapeshifters. They always speak of observing, learning and "slipping into" the essence, energies and energy "vibrations" of another animal. Or plant. Or even rock formation.
Tho I have no dogs, I watch Cesar Milan on National Geo and am struck with his firm educational insistence on fixing "people" problems to help dogs. And his persistant focus on maintaining a vibration level that the dog demands ... for a pack leader.
I never read the initial comments that Cesar's dog whispering with JonBee was considered "abusive" or "cruel." After all the Dog Whisperer episodes I have watched, I find it very odd that Cesar would have been "abusive" in the one episode I did not see.
I assume it was in the eye of the negative commenter. Hat's off to a modern day shapeshifter -- Dog Whisperer Cesar Milan. No accident that Cesar comes from Mexico, center of so many indigenous medicine men/women, curanderas and ... yes ... shapeshifters.
After seeing Cesar's interactions with his sons and his wife, as well as imbalanced dog owners, I'd have to say Cesar whispers to more than dogs!!
Last, a ditto to Bret Koehler, above, who said:
"It’s a sad commentary on society today when people see assertiveness, like that displayed by Cesar in the JonBee episode, and choose to interpret it as abuse."
AND
"I worked with two so-called expert trainers here in New York City to rehabilitate my rescued Jack Russell, Charlie. Their answer to every issue? Give food for good behavior, ignore dog for bad behavior. While both of these techniques have their role in dog training, I find it absurd that the majority of trainers these days are scared to discipline a dog!"
I worked at Sea World in California, which is reknowned for its cetacean training techniques that allow them to take urine and blood samples from 16,000 lb orcas, and that were exported to elephant caretakers at the world famous San Diego Zoo to painlessly trim elephant toenails!!
Yes, that is classic behavior training: rewarding good behavior (not always food; often toys, ice cubes, massages, etc.) and IGNORING wrong behaviors.
The reason that did nothing for Bret's Jack Russell is that NO ONE AT SEA WORLD IS TRYING TO BE PACK (OR POD) LEADER OF THE KILLER WHALES. The whales have worked out their own hierarchies, thank you very much. The reward-ignore training techniques are to get them to do natural behaviors, on cue, for ticket-paying show crowds.
Cesar Milan shapeshifts / whispers to what dogs need.
As a multi-dog owner obesessed with balanced training, I am an admirer of Cesar Millan after only seeing a few episodes of his show. However, the comparison that some have made here of JonBee's experience to a horse being "broken" is not a good one. On the surface, I can see why the comparison was made, but it's apples to oranges.
Mr. Millan shows us a way of dealing with and relating to dogs that acknowledges the way they think and perceive the world. He recognizes their basic drives, needs and instincts. Dogs are predators. Humans are predators. Horses are prey animals. Prey animal needs, instincts and ways of learning are often vastly different from predators. The reasons why horses buck, kick, bite and generally behave badly are different from what would cause a dog to behave badly. The traditional process of "breaking" a horse is usually the direct cause of the bad behavior displayed during the process. I think most people think that most horses start out as bucking broncs that must be tamed by "breaking." Not true. Even the most savage horse is not cured by traditional "breaking" methods.
"Breaking" represents the worst of horse/human relationships rather than the best. Vastly different from what Mr. Millan represents.
I would love to see an episode of the show that branches out a bit to demonstrate how we as human predators can relate better to each of our domesticated species. My guess is that Mr. Millan would quickly relate to other species of domesticated species.
Thank you for reading.
The episode with JonBee was one of the most brilliant of the whole series. For dogs that have dominated and misbehaved for so long the experience of being dominated is not pleasant, and to say it gets worse before it gets better was demonstrated perfectly. Cheers to Cesar for showing *all* of JonBee's transition - as un-pretty as it was, it was absolutely necessary for JonBee to experience submission in that explosive, cathartic way in order to surrender and move on. And cheers to his owners for being so committed and for believing in the dog they knew was in there all the time. I hope you all have a wonderful happy life together, you have great dog-karma.
I have just recently started watching Cesar's program. I think having seen him on "Oprah" cued my interest. The episode with Scott and Patrice Lincoln absolutely moved me to tears. What wonderful and unselfish people they are! As well, they used their hearts, intellect and resources to give this abused and violent animal, JonBee, every chance. And who better could they have contacted but Cesar? He is a "sensitive": highly intuitive to both animals and people, and it is truly a God-given gift.
He emanates authority, love, and respect, through the timbre of his voice, and the power of his hands. Not once have I seen him act abusively while watching consecutive episodes. Believe me, animals can sense those who don't like them, and if he behaved as such, they wouldn't even approach him.
Lesser people than the Lincolns would have put JonBee down a long time ago. And some veterinarians are no better, as this sort of advice tends to make their job a little easier.
I am so glad JonBee's life has turned around, in this loving home - what a truly lucky dog! I only wish Cesar had a branch here in New York; we could use him here.
P.S. - I am the owner of three cats, by the way. But even so, they also have to learn the meaning of "no", and be rewarded with lots of love and regard for their unique place in the scheme of things. We are very lucky to have animals; not only can they learn from us, but we must also be able to learn from them.
I have seen this show for about a year now and this one on JonBee was one of his tougher ones to date. I have tried to use technique of making the sound he uses and pointing my finger at my 11 month old Springer and she thinks that I'm playing. I have to come up with a different method and I don't know what yet. I have even used the bite method with her when I can react quick to what ever she is doing wrong. She has gone to obedience training and but sometimes you more then just that with some of the problems that some dogs might have. He is right when he says he has to retrain the owners and not the dogs.
IVE BEEN WATCHING CESAR EVER SINCE THE FIRST SHOW AND I THINK HE IS INCREDABLE. IVE SEEN HIM CHANGE SO MANY BREEDS OF BAD HABITS ALMOST LIKE MAGIC BUT THERE IS ONE BREED THAT IS AGRESSIVE, HIGHLY INTELLEGENT,BOSSY AND MORE HYPER THAN ALL BREEDS COMBINED AND THATIS THE JACK RUSSELL. I HOPE CESAR FINDS A CASE WITH ONE. A LOT OF PEOPLE WOULD LOVE TO SEE HOW HE HANDLES IT.
Wow! I am overwhelmed! I have 6 days to decide what to do with my Lexy, a 105lb German Shepherd. She is obediant in everyway, but is fear aggressive to visitors. She is prone to biting and has become an extreme liability in today's world. She is a fantastic family pet and she knows her place in the pack (obedianced trained and capable). I fear that we have done her some injustices along the way. She is good with our 2 and 3 year old, but before they came, we were a bit worried. I responded to bad advice and helped to "train" her to be hypervigilant in detecting visitors, cars, and people strolling by. This (and a few other incidents) has played a role in her becoming fear aggressive..........the more I read here and the couple of shows I've watched have helped me to realize that I probably caused this condition...years of training it "out" of her have been mildly successful. I gave up, and now she is biting and charging full tilt at unsuspecting visitors. I cant trust her off leash. On leash she does well and ofocourse, her success is very much dependent upon the emotion and body language with which I handle her. Everybody says to euthanize, but I see this as a tragedy that could have been avoided. She is currently being quaranteened for a recent bite, I look to learn more quick, in order to save her before this destroys our family in a lawsuit.
I am doing a debate project on resolved that dangerous breeds of dogs banned within municipality boudaries. I could use some helpful facts and information so id anyone could give me some i would appreciate it! :)
Dorothy~~~~~ Please look into what the city of Denver has done regarding the ban of breeds ie: pitbulls; Akitas; Chows; and other breeds that are high risk in violence tendency. Rather amazing
I am a big fan of Cesar Millian's show the Dog Whisperer. As I watch the show, I am fixed on how Cesar is able to rollar blade with ease with those "cool" skates on when running with his pack for exercise. Well, I decided to get motivated myself with my "pack", but my old fashioned skates aren't the same as Cesar's. Cesar, I am asking you ... where can I get a pair of those "cool" skates for me? I live in a one horse town ... McAllen, Texas on the Texas - Mexico border. I really want to get drain the energy of my one chihuahua "Venus" and kids, so I can better train them all, as a pack leader. I would really, really like a pair of your skates! Help me, please ... write or answer back at my e-mail GonzalezRb@aol.com.
Sincerly,
L.G. Gonzalez
one of your biggest fan in the Lone Star state next to my mom and dad, Mr. and Mrs. A. Guerra.
PS
I finished your book! I had a blast reading it!
My sister has a two year old female Doberman that kills family dogs. Her daughter, who doesn't live at the house, has another older female Doberman. When the other dog visits it aggravates the situation with the other dogs. My sister's dog kills rabbits and is a vicious killer with pets. After savagely attacking and killing a border collie pet, she is now intent on getting the pet Corgie. They are kept appart. My 94 year old mother is scared of the dog but my sister won't get rid of it. Is there a reason to be concerned.
Pete
Dear Cesar, I live in Santa Ana, Calif. and would like your help please. I have a one year old Maltese named Graci. I have been having trouble potty training her and my 8 year old dog named Cloe. They get into the trash, bark a lot and Graci doesn't let me brush her. If I do, she bites me. She's a Maltese-she needs to be brushed! These two little dogs are causing me much trouble. I'll walk them but when we come into the house, they pee and well, #2. It's gross! They won't listen to me. They are kind but they also sometimes really get at each other and its sort of like a mini dog fight. I've also tried to teach Grace to shake hands but every time I go for help paw, she bites me. I could really use your help as I have seen shots of you in the southern California area, it seems like my place wouldn't be that much out of your way. If you could possibly contact me I would so greatly appreciate it. Bring your family and I'll treat you to a BBQ. Stay well, and take care. The world needs more wonderful people like you. Thank you for any type of response. Respectfully, Rebecca Potter, Southern California.
Dear Cesar, We love your show.We are glad you show the american public that ALL breeds are not bad like the pitbulls,rottwilers and dobermans. These dogs are all able to be loving, wonderful companions like any other breed. Maybe people will open their eyes one day and realize that it is bad people not bad dogs. Dogs are only as smart as their owners are. Stupid people make stupid dogs. We love you and keep up the good work. Thanks from Union Grove Alabama.
Please somebody find out where to get that pool! I have been all over the internet looking. I even e-mailed Ceaser, but since i am from Michigan i get no response(i had an e-mail sent to tell me that). I have a chocolate lab that would so benefit frrom that pool. If any of you all are able to find out i would sooooo appreciate it! Thanks from Michigan!
Know its been asked many time....where is the info on the in-line skates? Really want a pair.
Thanks.
Ceasar's Skates
Check out http://www.landroller.com/
Have fun.
Yeah i wouldlove to know where he gets his pools too. The skates can be found in sharper image too
I just got a 2 1/2 yr old Pit Bull male that is loving but seems to have very little training. He is deaf and can be agressive towards cats and other dogs. I have two other dogs and one of them is a mix breed Lab/Shar Pei which within himself wants to be the leader between him and Chunck, a real future problem if I am unable to get a handle on them NOW! I need to understand what is the best way to train a deaf Pit Bull, because I understand that the Pit is not exactly like other dogs, they can be more agressive, hard headed, and yet very loving. The Pit's name is Chunck, he will bark excessively when left in my pickup or in the house, its like he feels he will never see me again. I need some direction on the correct way to start training a deaf Pit Bull. Thanks
Oh yes - a show about a Jack Russell would be great. We have a lovely little 8 month girl but she is certainly a handful. High energy and stubborn - regular obedience classes were fun but not of great use for this breed. She is certainly not a regular dog.
I saw your program for the first time 06/19/06 and was really impressed to say the least! We have a 5 year old male Boxer who is very loving but overdoes it welcoming visitors at the door. I have him broke of jumping on the person but jumps around just goes crazy when they come in, and has a really bad habit of taking food off the end tables, counter in kitchen etc. I know there are thousands of people contacting you daily I am sure but maybe at some point you could do a segment on Boxers.
Cesar,
I recently started watching your show because of the problems I'm having with my Rotie. She is very aggressive towards other dogs. She has bitten several other dogs, but they did not require stitches. When walking her she becomes out of control when she sees another dog. I live in Wisconsin. I was wondering if you could recommend a behaviorist/trainer in our area to work with us to correct this behavior.
Don
CESAR, this is not a success story but a cry for help!!
My daughter and son-in-law have two, one year old Chinese Shar-Pei girls from the same liter. China is a doll except she likes to eat anything she gets her teeth on including the door frames and Big Girl is also a doll except she does't like black people, small children, and anybody in or outside our family that she does't know. My great nephew just had a liver transplant at the University of Birmingham. My niece was taking him to the Kirklin Clinic for a check-up. Since my daughter lives in Pelham, AL , she thought it would be a good idea if my niece and nephew stayed at her house so she wouldn't have far to drive since they live in Columbus, MS. Big Girl would not have that. My niece stood inside the door and Big Girl tried to bite her and because my daughter told he no, she tried to bite her. She listens to my son-in-law but he was at work. My daughter needs to learn how to get a handle on her and Big Girl needs to learn how to listen. My daughter is just not firm enough. PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE HELP...... When you e-mail me back I will give you her address and directions to her house. PLEASE HELP
Thank you
Hey Cesar! I wanted to ask you the same question as L.G. Gonzalez regarding the "cool" skates you use. I'm very interested in getting a pair to take my dog for a walk but have come up unsuccessful in my search. Any help is greatly appreciated.
Hey Ceasar
I have a 6 month old chocolate female lab and still cant seem to get potty trained. she is detructive in the house particularly when she is left alone. she tears up things and gets into things and trashes the house.what can i do. how can i get her to stop and finally get her potty trained where she will go outside instead of inside. when you take her outside she just looks at you and wants to come back in. i also have a cat inside and the dog wont leave him alone so i have to keep him shut up most of the time because she eats the cat food and gets in the litter box. my dogs name is cocoa. please help
thank you
http://www.ringtones-dir.com/get/ ringtones site free. Download ringtones FREE, Best free samsung ringtones, Cingular ringtones and more. From website .
Dear Cesar, I have a 2 1/2 yr old pit/boxer mix named Champ and I have a 1 1/2 yr APBT named Dom. I have recently been having problems with Dom. He is trying to fight any other dog that comes around and has now attacked Champ who he has lived with his entire life. They both slept with me every night in the past and now I have had to lock Dom in his kennel. He growls everytime the other one is around.. They can't even be together anymore. I don't want to get rid of him but I really dont know what else to do.. I need your help. Thanks
Dear Cesar,
We have a 2 1/2 year old chow,rottweiler, and golden retreiver mix. He weighs about 115 lbs. He does not like it when you go near his fresh meat that you give him. He attacked me while I was giving him another spare rib and tore about a 4 inch chuck in my hand, I had to go to the emergency room. He is very protective of me...if any of the family members wake up in the morning and he is with me , he stands up and gets right near me and worns the family by his body language to not come closer. If there is not food around , like fresh meat, he is a very loving dog. I am concerned though on his aggressiveness. I need your help.
Thank you.
What a great site, how do you build such a cool site, its excellent.
This site is one of the best I have ever seen, wish I had one like this.
I have just found out about the dog Whisper...I have an 8 mo. old Border Collie mix. I was told by a trainer that dog food with the first ingredient as corn is bad. She said it messes with the tostorine (spell) in the brain making the dogs hyper. i have switched to a food with meat as the first ingredient. I am also concerned, we have had the dog on a chain for the last few weeks because she chases cars. now she is getting aggressive. i have since moved her to a building behind our garage which she loves to go into. I can walk her on a leash but she pulls. I just can't get her to stay down. my legs 7 arms are scratched & bruised daily. i do not want to give up on her, I truly love her despite the problems. I would be interested in any help on how i can control her.
Descriptions of poker pubs their atmospheresxqq
One thing that I know Buster likes to do is rest. When he is tired, he finds a place 驾校on the floor that he likes and he lies down. Sometimes he chews on his bone or his toy, and other times he likes to take a nap. www.51jiaxiao.com
My faimly and me have a dog that we got from the pound.His name is spanky.He is a pointer mix,he's really nice but he has 2# probloms when we leave him home alone for a while he trashs the house and sometimes when we play with him he gets agressive and we need help -laney and family thank you our number is 379-1215
my faimly and i have 2 dogs we had one and a friend gave us the other one.they are pitbulls there names are buddy and jd .they are good dogs but they have a few probloms one problom is they jump the fence and site in the front yard barking at people walking by and they chase cars .Lately we have to keep them seperate becuase they fight alot.the last fight buddy almost lost his eye .we are scard that one might realy hurt the other or we will have to give one away. They used to be the best of freinds till they turned 2 yrs old, both are nutered we did that after the first fight. When we leave them alone they trash the house and the back yard .
we need help but we dont live in any stats you go to we live in arizona. Atlanta, GA; Chicago, IL; New York, NY; Cleveland, OH; Los Angeles, CA
We have a 3 year old female Husky Malamute mix named Patches. She is a very sweet loving dog to the family ( our 18 month old son can pull her fur, ears and tail and she will just lay there and when she has had enough she walks away ) If anyone other than our family comes into our house she becomes agressive, her hair stands up on her back she grawls and shows her teeth. She has never bitten anyone but I worry. Also she is a scavinger any food left out unwatched she will take it. She knows it's bad because when she gets caught she tucks her tail and runs away.
Hello Cesar first it of all i just want to say i love your show and how you really put so much care into the pets really nice of you but now after seem your show for the longest in haven't quite find a question for my problem and i pray i can get and answer for this.. That deal is my 6 month old beagle name Max (cutest and sweetest dog) but because he is so sweet i had the problem that every time i take him out to walk he jumps to any one walking next to us which for some people might get annoying but the worst is that he pees as well so people are not very happy I'm kinda used to that but i have a hard time to take him out may be there is a solution for that or an advise my other problem is that when i take him out he loves to sit with me while I'm driving at the beginning i though it was okay but he has got bigger that is got so hard for me that i actually got pull over by the police any ways Cesar if you read this please advise me if what i can do thank you and keep doing a good job .......
please let me know southflgrl23@gmail.com
Im having problems with two of my five dogs. They are one year old pit/rott/mix, they have behavioral problems. Our neighbor has written us letters complaining about the barking at night and threatening to call the animal shelter on them. They jump on us bark, dig, and are scared to be on leashes. I would like to get in contact with ceasar to ask how i can get him to help mine and my dogs problems.
I watched the program 2 times, I didn't see anything inhumane or rough treatment of the dog. I have grown up with dogs I am 56 and my dad just turned 84 and as long as i can remember we always had dogs. The way Cesar handled the dog was a lot better than the way he would have been handled by my dad or his hunting buddies. Now that would have been rought treatment. I am totally amazed how Cesar can watch a dog for only a few seconds and know what the problem is. Keep up the good work and god I wish you were in North Carolina I got a toy rat terrier iI would love you to work with!
dear cesar,
we have a rottwhler who is 8 months in age & in one word he is uncontrolable. what advise can you provide us with these types of dogs...no, it was not by choise but rather a gift from a love one (which means i can't get rid of him) and to be honest the dog has grown in me. please help!!
-norma & luis (& jack--our dog)
THE FEAR MY DOG & I have WALKING DOWN MY STREET BECAUSE OF THE OFF LEASH dogs that HAVE RUN UP TO US IN THE PAST.
And I am angry, because i bought him for a walking buddy. I feel also, he is not getting the excercise he needs.
The Breeder I have asked for suggestions, & she has advised a SHOCK COLLAR. I don't agree with that.
I'm married with 2 boys, 5 & 7 & I figured--it's a good time for a puppy. SO-I investigated breeds & decided on a Sheltie. We have Scooter now since December of 2005 & he will be turning 10 months.
I read a lot before I got him-but obviously not the "right" stuff.
I took him for walks daily ,~ 2 miles a day when I first got him up until about the age of 7 months.
I started obedience training when he was 4 1/2 months & we really ace the classes. And we do continue classes, because we are successful there & feel safe there.
OUR PROBLEM IS WE HAVE A # of UNLEASHED DOGS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD that on a few occassions have run up to us on our walks & literally scared the living you know what out of us. Dogs such as german shepard, boxer (who actually started mounting Scooter), black lab mix, beagle mix, & even the 2 SHelties next door.
I think it is unfair to us (me & my dog) I DEFINITELY FREEZE UP.
So, now my dog and I have developed a fear aggression together. How can I make him feel safe when I am frightened myself? Now, when we are out in my yard, all he has to do is hear the tags of other dogs and it sets him off.
FRUSTRATED in Northern NJ
First of all I want to say that Ceaser Millian is a very intelligent man that can keep his cool towards dogs of all sorts. I comend him for that, but my story is a little more complicated than I've seen him handle. So if anyone can pass on this information I'm greatful. My dog Josie a full blooded miniture rat terrior and a very smart dog almost too smart. She listens, but she's very skidish with people, other dogs,and men. I know I know funny huh. Well her last owner was male and he didn't treat her with kindness. When I first got jo jo she was 3lb under weight, had no hair, and had severe teeth problems. The teeth were so badly brown from eating her feces among the other dogs feces caged with her. I rescued her in the middle of the winter like this, up north louisiana, at the time there was about 30 something dog in the fincinaty. Wanted to rescue all but could only take one. I immediatly fell in love and vows to take care of her. So far she has socialized with everyone at my job(12 people), but looks at me for reassurance. She'll kennal up when told, but only a little coaxing then once in I can't get her out sometime. Another thing, how do I make her stop crouching when i go to touch her; she cowards down as if I'm going to hit her and never even as much spanked her for any wrong doing? What i basically want to know is how can i get her to trust again and play like a normal 4 yr old dog should?
Concerned pet owner
I love to watch your show. It is very neat how you handle those dogs without being a bit frightned. I would like to ask a question though. My grandma's dog is a small english bulldog. Whenever we come to her house we see him peering through the door and waiting to jump on us. He has a bad problem with jumping on people to the point of leaving deep scratches on your body. My grandmother does not believe that her cute little bulldog has a problem. I love going to her house and spending time with her. I don't want to quit going over there but is there anyway I can fix this problem on my own. Any advice would be very helpful. Thank you.
Sincerly,
Scratched grandaughter
We have just brought a Puggle puppy home. She was 8 weeks old and is now 4 and half months old. We are doing our best to be calm and assertive with her and enusrung that she is walked daily. She is being crate trained and is doing very well with it. The challenge that we are having is the way that she is treating our children. We have a 2 year old, a 4 year old and an 8 year old. She treats them ( especially the 4 year old) like her litter mates. By that I mean she jumps and nips at them. We give her firm no's and show the kids how to be calm with her, but to no avail. Any ideas on how to curb this behavior?
Please help me. My dog will be put to sleep on August 17, 2006. He is only 1 1/2 years old. He is a mixed black lab. He is very intelligent but his severe aggression is out of control for the whole family. I am running out of time. Please respond.
I have a tea-cup chihuahua named Harley and his is almost a year old. When ever he gets excited or when ever anyone goes to pet him he pees every where. I have tried to put dippers on him put they leave a rash on his skin. I was wondering if there was any tips or advice that you could give me and Harley to help us him with his problem, I would greatly appreciate it!!!!! Please respond.
I had a 12 year old shih-tzu that died Saturday. She had
glacoma in both eyes severly.Along with her I have a 1 year
and 8 months shih-tzu. Since my 12 year old shih-tzu was old she would sometimes sit on the couch right next to me.
I never allowed my 1 year old on the couch. Since she passed
away my 1 year old has been wanting to sleep on the couch.
Even though I tell him "no", he waits for me to leave then
he gets on the couch. I don't know if he is missing her or
he is trying to take her place. Please help if you can.
I have been watching Cesar shows and I think he is wonderful with dogs. He has a true gift! But my concern is, will I be able to do the same with my golden. She is not aggressive at all. She is very happy and loves people. But I can't walk her because she pulls me so hard, (I have had three back surgeries, and now have a rod in my spine.) She barks at people walking on the street, and will break through the invisible fence and run the neighborhood. My husband is getting very upset, and I do not want to give up my dog. I would love to walk her every day, how do I stop the pulling. I know I'm the one who needs to be trained and be the leader, but someone needs to tell her that.
hi my name is manuel hulsey i have a dog named kevin and my mom is getting mad because he scratches the doors and pees everywere so plz help us we want to keep our dog pleace email back before next week pleace.5734 marktwain ct.corona cal.
Add a Comment