Frantic Fella

I spent a lot of time, including two follow-up visits, working with Cindy Steiner and her daughter Sydney, trying to help their adorable terrier mix, Fella, overcome his separation anxiety. I've had many clients who have dogs that seem to be stable in almost every situation, except when the owner leaves the house. Separation anxiety seems to be an epidemic among the dogs of busy, working people, and that's not at all surprising. It is normal for a dog or pack-oriented animal to feel anxious or panicky when left alone. They are not programmed to be by themselves. Only rarely is a natural dog pack ever separated. But since most people must leave the house to work or run an errand, the best way to ease our dogs into this very unnatural situation is to make it as natural as possible for them. We can accomplish this is if we send them into a resting mode before leaving the house. First thing in the morning, wear your dog out with the most vigorous exercise possible. It's a win-win situation for us too because most of us could use a lot more exercise! And feed your dog after you exercise him, so he feels like he's earned his reward. After an ideal morning like that, it will make sense to a dog to rest when you leave. If this becomes their everyday routine, the anxiety will begin to taper off because a lot of that nervous energy will have been spent by the time you leave the house.
Categories: S2:Ep18:Bikini, Fella, and Winston & Oliver
26 Comments
0 TrackBacks

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://ngccommunity.nationalgeographic.com/admin/mt-tb.cgi/389

Add This:
StumbleUpon
Digg
Delicious
Face Book
Technorati
Digg

26 Comments

For everyone who has posted on this blog about separation anxiety, I hope you saw this episode "Frantic Fella" -- I am BLOWN AWAY by how Cesar changed this situation for the wonderful woman and her daughter, and of course "Fella" the dog. Absolutely, positively, the best stuff on television today. I was smiling and crying all at the same time!!

I agree, so many people have problems with separation anxiety and I was so happy to see Cesar show step by step how to address this problem. And it can help everyone, even those with dogs that do not have seperation anxiety. Same principles as always, leave the dog tired! :)

Cesar's step-by-step instructions for handling Fella are excellent. I have learned so much by watching his "Dog Whisperer" shows. I followed the way Cesar used the knocking on the door, opening it and shutting it and how he introduced Fella to the kennel. I was given an 8 yr old MinPin who loves her kennel, and I have left her in it for up to 4 hours as she sleeps a lot and is comfortable in it. If I had to be gone all day (8 hrs) could she be left in the kennel? I understand that she needs to be walked first, to relieve herself and to be tired. On the show, Cesar did not say whether or not the lady could leave Fella in the kennel while she went to work. Or did I just miss it?
Does anyone have an answer to this?

Edie-
The dog can be left in the crate during the time you are gone- Up to 8 hours. You are setting the dog up for success to be left out in the house with the crate door open and still not have accidents or be destructive. Make sure the dog sees the crate as a resting place, not a prison. Walk the dog before leaving it for long periods of time. Good Luck

My little dog suffers from separation anxiety, but he acts no different than at home with me. He's just all sleepy and tired and he curls up and rests when I'm gone. It doesn't seem like he suffers from separation anxiety, you say, but deep down, I know that my dog misses me more than ever, even though he acts as if nothing unusual has happened. Always remember that your dog still loves you even though he doesn't care if you're gone. Also remember to not feel bad about leaving your dog at home or in a shelter. They don't care; in the wild, the pack leaves all the time on hunts and adventures without one or two dogs. These tips should last you a while. Your Welcome!!

Hi, I have an 8 yr old Huskie (Karma) who has always suffered from separation anxiety. I recently moved which seemed to make it a thousand times worse. He's a perfectly well behaved dog when I'm with him, but when I leave the house, he becomes Mr. Destructive. I've tried taking him to the dog park before I leave for an hour of exercise, and then feeding him as a reward. I've tried doggie anxiety medication, I've tried Kong toys (they bore him). I've tried pretending to leave so he doesn't associate the keys, etc. as something bad. I make sure he's calm before I leave. I've even waiting until he was sleeping to leave. What else is there? Nothing has helped so far.

Merlyn,
Try crate training so that your dog has a safe place to rest while you're gone. Especially being in a new place, he might not feel as secure as he'd like.
Also, taking him to the dog park is not the same thing as taking him on a structured walk with him following you. Huskie's need a TON of exercise to tire them out b/c they were bred for long hauls, so you are going to have quite a job in tiring him out before you leave for the day. I would say a 45 minute power walk before you go would do the trick. Or if you have a bike or roller blades that will up the speed, this would be even better. Add on a backpack to increase the intensity.

Good luck, and don't give up. Seperation anxiety is a tricky thing to overcome. But keep practicing good leadership and definitely try the crate training.

Thanks so much for your suggestions. I tried crate training when he was much younger and he actually injured himself tearing the crate apart. I'm hesitant to try that again. Is there anything special about using the crate I should know that would keep Karma from hurting himself while I am away? I'm never gone more than 4 hours (I live close enough to come home at lunch from work).

I cannot exercise him by walking him because I am disabled. That's why I was taking him to the dog park to run. I've seen dogs on TV exercise on treadmills. How do you get him to stay on?

hi my dog does this too ! thanks for the information i will try it .... if not my mom want me to get rid of my dog he is a real barking machine whit no on off button ,it is terrible ,
by the way i love your show and i would like it to be in canada so that canadian peaple can watch it too ! i think that youre pretty good by the way . Have i nice days.

Tiffany hill

We acquired an injured 16 week old pit bull puppy last Tuesday. Found a knee surgeon last Thursday, he had surgery and came home last Friday (he had surgery to repair his totally blown out knee). In order to keep the puppy and our home safe we purchased a crate ~ he's not potty trained yet and we have a 7 year old 80 lb female pit bull who would not hurt him intentionally but by accident could harm his leg (they want to play!). Unfortunately we did not have the luxury of time to introduce him to the crate slowly and I think the prior owner 'locked' him up in a crate for long hours. For the few days we had prior to returning back to full time work, we fed him in his crate, gave him treats and praise every time he entered the crate on his own, did everything we could think of to present the crate as a safe place. The first time we left him was for a little over an hour and as far as we could tell he was quite. But with each day and the increased time in the crate (not more than 4 hours, average 2 to 3 at a time) he is increasingly making more and more noise (howling, barking, whining, etc.). Any tips on stopping this behavior and obtaining a peaceful home and quiet for our neighbors? HELP!

Hi Merlyn,
I'm so sorry to hear that he injured himself in the crate. Although I have heard of one other dog doing this as well. You want to make sure the dog is VERY tired when he is first introduced to the crate so that it will be an inviting place for him (b/c there is a nice soft bed in there hopefully). I would start by leaving the crate OPEN in the room wherever he is during the day. Place a yummy treat in there and some bedding. You can also start feeding him in his crate. Therefore he will associate being in the crate with good things. This might take a little patience (and time) on your part since you are going to have to UNDO what used to be a negative experience for him. Also, whatever kind of crate you had before (wire or plastic) I would see about getting the other kind. Some dogs respond better to the plastic (den-like) crate and others like the openness of the wire crate. As you work up to closing the door on the crate, I would make sure to supervise him for the first few days of this. You wouldn't want him to injure himself again.

Or, if your pup will just not have any part of being the crate no matter how patient you are, there is always the option of gating off a certain area of your home that is dog-proofed, meaning that he can't access anything that he might chew up or destroy. This might be a good way to work DOWN to the crate as well as you slowly decrease the space he has access to during the day until it is approximately the size of his crate. For an older dog that has plenty of bladder/bowel control, I would go ahead and get a crate that is big enough for him to stretch out in.

About the treadmill, I have not tried this with my dogs yet. But I plan to and was given great advice by another dog trainer on this blog. I will do some research on here and repost it for others who might be interested in the way to introduce the treadmill to a dog.

Since you cannot walk your dog, if it's possible to hire a dog walker or a family member who might be able to walk him a bit, that would be a wonderful activity to do BEFORE attempting the treadmill. Alot of dogs are fearful of the treadmill because it is something that they are not familiar with.

Good luck and I hope this can be of some help to you!

Here is post from this blog and the response is from Karen Dog Whisperer 2:

re; treadmill

P.L. ’state of mind’ s/b very ‘matter of fact’, no big deal, just another thing/place to ‘follow’ me to…

When I help owners with the treadmill (takes FOREVER for the owners to understand how beneficial this is for their ‘wacko’ dogs….), usually the first time with the dog is simply spent treating the treadmill as ‘just another thing to ‘trip’ over in the house’. I usually take the dog for a quick walk first and when entering their house go right to where the t.m. is (kinda a continuation of the walk?) I DO NOT hesitate or tense or even think about it. I walk over to it, step on it and step off the other side (make sure there is clearance on BOTH sides), turn, go out of the room, maybe go to get some water for Rover and continue the ‘House Walk’—When I’m ‘feeling’ the dog is ready, instead of the ’step on, step off’, I step on, ask for sit and we hang out for a bit (the t.m. is OFF). Or I ‘pretend’ to be looking in my pocket for something (usually have some ‘crinkle’ paper, really gets a dog’s attention—woof, possible treat here, what’s she got there?), and even if the dog doesn’t hold the sit (just so she’s not getting OFF, she’s distracted from it because she is picking up MY energy of: CALM, CONFIDENT, this thing we are on is simply NOTHING. Then we practice getting on and off, on and off. Or, I also step on with the dog, step off first and have them ‘wait’ on the t.m. for a second to become used to being on it alone. (Understand, this is SO hard to explain because I just usually go with my instincts and am not used to breaking everything down in detail with words; like anything, how I approach the ‘intro. to t.m.’ depends on the dog.) For some, that may be it until next time.

The key thing is to not ANTICIPATE that the dog is going to go ‘nuts’….you picture him/her ‘tucking tail’ and running and he/she will!!

When YOU feel ready, the next time the dog is on ’start your engines’ — there might be a quick ‘tense’ w/your dog, (well, gosh the earth is moving here, should I panic?) Oh, Dufus just relax….here ya go…wow, look at you….easy…etc. (For gosh sakes, make sure YOU are familiar with the t.m. ‘keyboard’ first, you don,t want to be fumbling all over pressing and beeping to get it turned on and to the correct setting!) Have a setting which will be a good steady pace for him (a ‘zone walk pace’) and then let him do it and don’t you stand there ‘holding’ him with your eyes….If you are worried he’s going to ‘fall off’, get hurt, be scared, etc. — if you are worried the setting is wrong, the leash is going to get tangled, what if…., what if….. — well, gosh, you are sure a wreck, if this is your energy around the t.m. then this t.m. ‘thing’ becomes a ‘negative’ energy zone (P.L. is a mess when she’s here, I’m getting nervous because of that, hey, I’m out of here!!!!)

My seven year old chiquaua mix is a perfect angel, until we open the front door. She will run out and not come back until she is ready (about 2 hours). Does anyone have any ideas to help me break her of this habit?

Thresa

Hi, my name is Susan. My dog is Shatten. He is a blue heeler that I got when he was 8 weeks old from an animal rescue shelter. I am unable to figure out another way to reach your organization. How much would it cost to have my dog rahabilatated at your center. When Shatten was about 10-12 weeks old he had a bad experience and I have never been able to get him over it. He was not an agressive puppy, however he was a very active puppy. He is very smart. I talk to him in both German and English and he seems to do well with both. He can identify different people by name and knows the difference between different toys. He can catch in the air. He knows most commands, sit, stay, heel, shake, lay and roll over. Alll this, he does pretty well. He will not come when I call him off leach and he is out but I think I can be taught to deal with this.

The big problem is men with caps. He hates men with caps. When he was about 10 weeks old, I had a guest at my home. Shatten was just being a puppy and started barking at the guest when the guest arrived and the guest barked back and stomped his feet at him and then growled at him. Shatten started yelping and crying and has never been the same since. My son in law has been bitten by him once because of his fear. He lunged at a small two year old one time. He is unpredictable. He tried to bite a neighbor. Much of the time is very good and does not exhibit any of this behavior and then all of a sudden out of the blue he will get aggressive. One day I had him at the post office. He was just standing by my side, when all of a sudden he saw a dark haired young man that he didn't like and he lunged at the guy. It was very disturbing. Can you help me with Shattens problems.

Ok, my husband and I LOVED the separation anxiety segment. We have 2 beagles. Bagel is 2 months older than Max. We've raised Bagel since puppyhood and he is absolutely fine with his crate. We crate trained him, he has no problem when we leave for work, etc. We got Max when Bagel was 1 year old from the shelter. Max was fine for the first few months in his new crate but then he started howling and howling when we'd leave. We did discover that he escaped from his crate a few times and he didn't destroy anything so we though they might be fine baby-gated into the kitchen. Max eventually discovered how to jump over the gate and actually did some damage (dug/ripped through the arm of our sofa). In the crate, in the kitchen and in the house, Max would defecate when we were gone (even if he had gone potty before we left).

We are ok with Bagel and Max being in the kitchen together when we're not home but we would like both dogs to be comfortable with their crates in case they do need to be crate trained for any reason (health, surgery, etc). We really like the idea of biking with the dogs but we also live in the Chicago suburbs so wintertime biking is really difficult due to a LOT of the sidewalks being iced over. During the winter, we tend to take the dogs to the park more frequently for their exercise because it's not as icy, it's safer for us to walk, etc.

So I'm looking for wintertime suggestions. I can power walk both the dogs for 45 minutes at a good pace whenever there's no ice on the walks but DH is physically unable to walk as fast a pace with me due to his leg. So what sort of "Chicago winter" type exercises can you suggest for us to do when the weather doesn't allow us to safely bike.

We're also wanting to re-introduce the boys to the crates as it is something that we want them to be comfortable staying in when we're gone or for any times where they might HAVE to be in the crates. So what's a good way to re-introduce the dogs to their crates in a healthy way so that 1: both dogs will be ok being in their own crate. 2. Max doesn't build up his anxiety when he's in the crate.

We have a couple options for crates. We have 2-36" wire crates and 1-24" wire crate. All of them have the removeable divider. Both beagles are 14.5 inches high and between 24-27 pounds. Just so you have an idea of how big of a dog we have vs. their crate sizes. We'd obviously prefer to utilize the crates we have since we've already purchased them.

So if any of you have suggestions on how we re-introduce the boys to their crates and also winter-time, cold weather exercise, that would be great! BTW, in the segment were the mom and daughter exercising Fella on the bikes in the evenings or morning??? We couldn't figure it out! Thanks!

Elsa,

In the winter, walk him at a pace that your dog chooses, and make sure it isn't too slow. The pace will be a little slower, so walk him for a longer time.

I inherited my brother's 5 year old American Eskimo a month ago when his twins turned two and the dog had developed some nipping behavior towards pizza delivery men and other strangers. He is the perfect dog in most ways - not destructive, doesn't bark, obedient, and affectionate. However, yesterday he snapped at a stranger who went to pet his head, and nipped my 7 year old niece who approached him to put a leash on. He was sitting next to me when this happened and I instinctively put my hand down between the dog and my neice to keep him from hurting her - he then bit me in several places on my arm, breaking the skin. I'm not sure how to correct this behavior, since he doesn't display any aggression towards my husband or I when we are home alone. Now I'm afraid to take him for a walk where we might encounter strangers, or have him around any children. Any ideas?

Hi everyone, this was one of the few episodes we missed and really needed. We have a 10 month old German Shorthaired Pointer, Chloe, who is quickly learning she is no longer the leader of our pack (thank you Cesar!) Most of her undesirable behaviors that WE created have subsided since implementing Cesar's philosophy.

However, there's a big problem we can't figure out how to fix. She came to us from the breeder crate trained, but somehow we screwed that up because she paces, drools, cries and bites at the wires when in the crate. So we let her have free reign when we leave the house, but she has chewed rugs, couch arms, curtains, door jams, etc. But then other times, she doesn't touch a thing. Any suggestions on reintroducing the crate or desensitizing her to our leaving are truly appreciated. Good luck to all of you!

Help! I have a 5-month year old Bichon Frise that will not stop screaming when we leave the house! She is crate trained at night, but whether in her crate or in the kitchen behind a gate, she screams and screams. She also refuses to walk on a lease unless in front... I have ATTEMPTED cesar's techniques, but every time I try and show her I mean business, she looks at me like it is play time!

I have a problem, however, it's not with my dog, it's me. Let me explain..... My fiancee and I adopted a Beagle/Border Collie mix from a rescue shelter a little over 2 years ago. We love him very much and he is such a great addition to our home! However, ever since then I have become anxiuos, constantly worried about him, and have developed OCD only when it comes to the dog. He does great in our apt. when we are at work during the day. We allow him to run free in our apt. The reason behind that is he has tried to tear apart his crate with his teeth and has hurt himself before. He has not had any accidents, no barking (that I am aware of). However, my maternal instincts go in overdrive, we do not have any children yet. I imagine every possible thing that could happen to him when we are gone. Such as the front door opening and he running away, a fire starting and he would be stuck inside, the list goes on. It's driving me nuts that I think of these things and is putting a real starin on my fiancee and I. I realize this is not a typical question, but if anyone has any suggestions or advice...it would be greatly appreciated!!

i love the show... every show! but i have a question, ive never seen you deal with a problem that my mini weiner dog has. my dog has a problem with peeing everytime someone new comes over, or gets excited or scared. i dont know how to fix it. he is still a puppy and will turn 6 months on the 12th of this month. we are taking him to get neutered on the 25th of the month, will the peeing ever stop?!?!?! please help!

Hi Kaleen,
My puppy used to do that when someone new would come over. With her, it was a matter of her being shy and overly excited. I would suggest ignoring him (and having others do this as well) until he is able to calm down. If he is allowed to greet a new-comer in a normal (for a dog) way, he should overcome this fearful/submissive urination. Just tell your guests: I'm sorry, but he gets too excited if you talk/pet/look at him right away. Hopefully this will work for you! Good luck!

I, too, had a spearation anxiety issue with a mentally abused Schnauzer I adopted. When we left the house, she uprooted plants and generally re-arranged the entire house. Unfortunately, I did not know of Cesar so I set out to see how to handle this. I stumbled on the fact that when they were with us in the back seat of the truck, As we were leaving them, I told them "wait & stay" with stern voice while holding my hand-palm towards them. Never an issue. Quite by accident, I accidentally used that same practice when leaving home and there has not been another incident in 5 years. This dog is now an assisted therapy dog in local care centers.
Cesar is amazing and I stumbled...........

We have a 1 year old Shar Pei/Yellow Lab mix who is untrustworthy to be off a dog run in our yard. She will dash and visit all our neighbors. So my problem is if we put her on the run and ignore her by doing chores inside and out she will go into the garden and dig a hole. We are not sure how to stop this behavior. Any help would be appreciated

I just picked up a new puppy-8 week old Newfoundland/Chesapeake Bay Retriever mix. He's having a hard time when he's not in the same room as I am. Barking/whining/even some howling! Can I expect this behavior to get better as he grows?

Hi Sportsterguy,
This type of behavior is natural for such a young pup. Give him some time to adjust to not being with his litter mates and I'm sure the behavior will lessen. Just make sure to not give any affection to him when he is carrying on. You can give him a few light verbal corrections, such as "No" or "Shh", but just keep in mind that he is trying to acclimate himself into a new situation. I would definitely suggest crate training, if you haven't started already. When introduced correctly, they can be a life saver!

To introduce the crate, make sure it is always a positive experience and do not shut the crate door right away. Make sure he is comfortable and chewing on a yummy treat and once he has settled, then close the door. It can be frightening at first since it is closed in and they can't get out, but if done slowly, they can learn to LOVE their crate.

Good luck with your little pup! I know how exciting/exhausting this time can be! :)

Add a Comment

NAT GEO NEWSLETTER

Always Know What's On!