New Orleans High - Day In, Day Out
Daphna Rubin
Hoggard Films
The thought I carried around with me while we were making this film is how did these young people end up where they are today? And what role does their public high school play in their lives? Can it stand up to the influences of a place like New Orleans? We've all read about the decline of our nation's public school systems and the various initiatives to change them. This is no great epiphany. But for me, witnessing these students' lives firsthand and the vastly under-resourced school that tries to face all the challenges that come along with them were eye-opening experiences. How did we get here? And why aren't we more concerned especially when the stakes are so high?
There's a lot of talk about education in this country but essentially it's left up to local districts to figure it out no matter what resources they have. Holding educators and schools accountable does not seem to be a workable solution when the problems we witnessed were myriad and extended well beyond the schoolyard.
Not only do these young people contend with the same issues that any teenager faces - acceptance, confidence, self-esteem, etc. - but many of them carry the extra burdens that come along with life in places that are often dangerous and dysfunctional.
In some of the first video diary entries that came back, the students' descriptions of life in New Orleans ranged from not knowing whether you would survive from one day to the next to how close they'd come to extraordinary tragedy in their lives... a parent being assaulted, the death of a sibling, the murder of a friend, the absence of an imprisoned father... There wasn't one student who deviated from this experience. And there wasn't one among them who described the New Orleans beloved by tourists around the world though many described New Orleans as a city they will always love.
The educators I met with in New Orleans spoke of several challenges. The post-Katrina educational system divides schools up into 5 districts. Some schools have the option to be selective. In the end this translates into kids with negligent parents or low test scores or other chronic problems being dumped into the same school. One teacher I met described it as a form of 'apartheid.' Some argue that these kids and their schools would be better off if they were mixed in with kids from different backgrounds. Another problem that a New Orleans high school principal shared with me is the economy that these kids will enter if they stay in New Orleans. The jobs that they will compete for often alongside their parents are minimum wage, service-oriented jobs that frankly don't require a high school diploma much less a college degree.
Overwhelmingly in the evenings when I returned to the crew apartment in New Orleans - completely exhausted and trying to make sense of all the loose ends and stories that were fomenting but could still end nowhere - I often thought about what a microcosm these kids lived in. It's almost as if they don't live in America. Many have no connection to the opportunity that this country can afford though there were many opportunities at the school to try and forge those connections.
What I took away from the experience was that it is possible and necessary to have an impact often just one kid at a time. And that sometimes, despite your best efforts, there's no way to save them from themselves. I also came away from the experience with a deep sense of admiration for the teachers and administrators who walked into Cohen everyday grateful to have an opportunity to make a difference in the lives of their students.
Inside New Orleans High premieres Sunday, October 26 at 10p e/p.
Preview the show by going to the Inside New Orleans High show page.
No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: http://ngccommunity.nationalgeographic.com/admin/mt-tb.cgi/1896
Recent Blog Comments
- I'm not so sure I believe... on 9/11 Science and Conspiracy Director's Diary
- Top international scientists have proven beyond... on 9/11 Science and Conspiracy Director's Diary
- I happen to watch this documentary... on On pursuit to film an extraordinary story in India - Part 2
- I just read Daddy's story. He... on HAPPY 40th BIRTHDAY, Cesar!
- Happy Birthday Cesar. I love your... on HAPPY 40th BIRTHDAY, Cesar!
Monthly Archives
- August 2009 (12)
- July 2009 (16)
- June 2009 (20)
- May 2009 (5)
- April 2009 (10)
- March 2009 (10)
- February 2009 (12)
- January 2009 (14)
- December 2008 (6)
- November 2008 (9)
- October 2008 (7)
- September 2008 (10)
- August 2008 (10)
- July 2008 (19)
- June 2008 (14)
- May 2008 (11)
- April 2008 (16)
- March 2008 (13)
- February 2008 (14)
- January 2008 (16)
- December 2007 (11)
- November 2007 (15)
- October 2007 (12)
- September 2007 (12)
- August 2007 (11)
- July 2007 (3)
- June 2007 (10)
- May 2007 (7)
- April 2007 (4)
- March 2007 (9)
- February 2007 (5)

Add a Comment